Scalable management plane for a modular network element

ABSTRACT

Systems and methods of managing a modular network element as a single entity and the modular network element includes a plurality of line modules and zero or more switch modules in a chassis. The plurality of line modules are located separate from the chassis and connected to the chassis and/or to one another via cabling. The method includes operating a management plane between the plurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules via one or more dedicated links in the cabling; managing the plurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules as a single network element utilizing a chassis management protocol over the management plane; and designating one of a controller in the chassis and a processor in one of the plurality of line modules operating as a virtual controller as primary for the chassis management protocol.

FIELD OF THE DISCLOSURE

The present disclosure generally relates to networking systems andmethods. More particularly, the present disclosure relates to a modularnetwork element architecture which combines rack mounted units (i.e.,“pizza boxes”) and chassis-based systems to provide flexibility,scalability, efficiency, etc., i.e., a hardware platform which cansupport multiple applications including optical/photonic networking,Time Division Multiplexing (TDM), packet switching, etc.

BACKGROUND OF THE DISCLOSURE

Networks, data centers, cloud infrastructure, etc. are realizedultimately through physical hardware. The physical hardware is used torealize networking, computing, and/or storage functions includingoptical/photonic networking, Time Division Multiplexing (TDM), packetswitching, etc. Conventionally, there are generally two approaches forhow physical hardware is deployed—through a chassis and associatedmodules or through a rack mounted unit. A chassis-based system includesa chassis with multiple slots and a backplane which support differentmodules, line cards, circuit packs, blades, etc. (for simplicity, theseare referred to as modules). The chassis-based system allows deploymentflexibility where modules as-needed or required are selectively insertedin the chassis. The chassis includes an electrical (Printed CircuitBoard (PCB)) backplane, fixed-size modules, shared power and cooling forall of the modules, a central switch fabric such as through one or moremodules, etc. Other advantages of a chassis include power installationonce for the chassis, front access only, redundancy, tight coupling ofsoftware and hardware, etc.

There are several fundamental challenges, namely 1) PCB backplanes arebecoming limited in their ability to support higherSerializing-Deserializer (SERDES) rates at the same Fabric-to-Moduledistances, 2) the industry business model that led to these types ofdesigns is changing, 3) consumption patterns on life-cycle anddepreciation practiced by network operators, that is in turn reinforcedby the merchant Application Specific Integrated Circuit (ASIC) supplychain, connote requirements for greater modularity, and the like. Thatis, the conventional chassis-based approach is centralized with a fixedform-factor which limits flexibility in size, power, and the ability toaddress different applications. Further, the chassis-based approachrequires a lock-in ahead of time, suboptimal faceplate use, fixed slotsizes and power, fixed cooling, fixed slot bandwidth, etc. Thechassis-based approach requires a large initial investment.

The rack mounted unit is also referred to as “pizza boxes” and generallyinclude 1-2 (or more) Rack Unit (RU or simply U and which is a standardunit of measurement of 44.5 mm or 1.75″) high completely enclosed formfactor. The rack mounted unit differs from a chassis in that all of thehardware is already included as the rack mounted unit is deployed. Forexample, data centers realize network elements such as in a leaf/spinearchitecture in a completely decentralized and modular form using rackmounted units. Advantages of the rack mounted unit approach includestandard interfaces, stackability, low cost, adaptability, low first-incost and pay as you go, etc. While this provides flexibility, thisapproach has interconnect complexity, such as massive amounts of cablingin the front and this cabling is based on pluggable optics which lackthe density achievable in chassis-based approach. Also, this approachdoes not include redundancy, expansion to larger systems is complex andinefficient, and each install requires a power connection.

BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE DISCLOSURE

As PCB backplanes of current sizes probably only have two generations oflink speed left, there will be a transition to electrical cabledbackplanes and then to optical cabled backplanes. Many are viewing thecabled systems as simply a replacement for the PCB backplane that offerbetter signal integrity. However, cabled backplanes offer an entirelynew way of thinking about platform design which is not simply a directreplacement for the PCB backplane.

Accordingly, it would be advantageous to provide a hybrid hardwarearchitecture between the fixed chassis-based approach and the completelydecentralized rack mounted unit.

In an embodiment, a modular network element includes one or morelineboxes which are a hybrid between a rack mounted module and a linemodule which is inserted in a chassis; one or more linebox carrierswhich are rack mountable and configured to selectively receive the oneor more lineboxes and provide power connectors and data connectorsthereto; and a core chassis including one or more switch modules, one ormore controller modules, and a set of connectors located at the rear forcabling to the power connectors and the data connectors on the one ormore linebox carriers. The one or more lineboxes can include a pluralityof faceplate ports connected to fabric circuitry communicatively coupledto the one or more switch modules via the cabling; and the one or moreswitch modules can be connected to one another and the one or morecontroller modules via a midplane or cables.

The cabling can include one or more of electrical cabling with aplurality of pairs of coaxial cable and optical cabling. Each cablebetween a linebox and the core chassis can include a plurality ofbundles each having a plurality of links and a number of the pluralityof bundles is based on a number of the one or more switch modules. Achassis management protocol can be implemented between the one or morelineboxes and the core chassis, and the one or more lineboxes and thecore chassis can be managed as a single entity. The chassis managementprotocol can implement, between the one or more lineboxes and the corechassis, timing synchronization, presence, status, ownership,interrupts, reset, power, and position identification. The one or morecontroller modules provide power and connectivity to circuitry on eachlinebox for establishing the chassis management protocol to power thelinebox on and off. The core chassis can include an access panel thatsupports the core chassis and each of the one or more lineboxes. Each ofthe one or more lineboxes can include a display which provides a virtualslot number based on a relative position in a rack.

The one or more lineboxes can include a plurality of lineboxes with atleast two lineboxes having a different pitch. The one or more lineboxescan include a plurality of lineboxes with at least two lineboxes havingone or more of a different number of faceplate ports and a differenttype of pluggable optics. The one or more lineboxes each can include anEthernet switch which connect to another Ethernet switch in the one ormore switch modules. The one or more linebox carriers can includeretractable pins with a spring-loaded mechanism that grabs into holes inrails on a rack and which has a push to disengage mechanism enablingfront-only access to the rack. The one or more linebox carriers can haveslack in the cabling to the core chassis allowing movement up and downthe rack.

In another embodiment, a method of deploying a modular network elementincludes connecting a linebox slot carrier to a rack; providing alinebox in the linebox slot carrier, wherein the linebox is a hybridbetween a rack mounted module and a line module which is inserted in achassis, and wherein the linebox slot carrier connects the linebox topower connectors and data connectors; and providing a core chassisincluding one or more switch modules, one or more controller modules,and a set of connectors located at the rear with cabling to the powerconnectors and the data connectors on the linebox slot carrier. Themethod can further include providing a second linebox to a secondlinebox slot carrier responsive to increase capacity of the modularnetwork element. The second linebox can be added to the core chassisin-service.

In a further embodiment, a modular network element includes one or morelineboxes which are a hybrid between a rack mounted module and a linemodule which is inserted in a chassis, each of the one or more lineboxesincluding a plurality of faceplate ports connected to fabric circuitryand a processor; and one or more linebox carriers which are rackmountable and configured to selectively receive the one or morelineboxes and provide power connectors and data connectors thereto. Theone or more lineboxes can include a plurality of lineboxes collectivelyforming a mesh therebetween via the data connectors, and one of theplurality of lineboxes can be designated as a primary linebox forimplementing a virtual controller of the modular network element via theprocessor. A core chassis can be added in-service to increase capacityof the modular network element, the core chassis can include one or moreswitch modules, one or more controller modules, and a set of connectorslocated at the rear for cabling to the power connectors and the dataconnectors on the one or more linebox carriers.

In an embodiment, a method of Ethernet path selection is performed in amodular network element including one or more ingress line modules, aplurality of switch modules in a chassis, and one or more egress linemodules, wherein the one or more ingress line modules and the one ormore egress line modules are located separate from the chassis andconnected to the chassis via cabling. The method includes distributingone or more Ethernet flows from the one or more ingress line modules tothe one or more egress line modules via the plurality of switch modules;receiving fabric state information at the one or more ingress linemodules from the chassis out-of-band via the cabling; and, responsive tocongestion on a path through the plurality of switch modules, selectinga new path by an ingress line module for an Ethernet flow. The methodcan further include, prior to switching the Ethernet flow to the newpath, creating a gap in the Ethernet flow through buffering such thatthe gap is no larger than a path delay difference between a current pathand the new path. A size of the gap can be set to a latency of thecurrent path minus a latency of the new path plus a margin.

The method can further include distributing a Time Division Multiplexing(TDM) flow by fragmenting the TDM flow and sending over a plurality ofpaths through the plurality of switch modules. The method can furtherinclude distributing timing from the chassis out-of-band via thecabling, wherein the timing is determined at the chassis using a TimeDivision Multiplexing (TDM) flow which is spread over the plurality ofswitch modules. The chassis can utilize a TDM packet header to estimaterelative path latency differences. The method can further includebroadcasting a path selection by each ingress line module to all otherline modules and the chassis for each to maintain a global path table.The Ethernet flow can include an elephant flow and each flowburst of theelephant flow is eligible to take a different path if its interburst gapis larger than a difference in latency between a current path and thenew path.

In another embodiment, a modular network element configured for Ethernetpath selection includes one or more ingress line modules; one or moreswitch modules in a chassis; and one or more egress line modules,wherein the one or more ingress line modules and the one or more egressline modules are located separate from the chassis and connected to thechassis via cabling, wherein one or more Ethernet flows are distributedfrom the one or more ingress line modules to the one or more egress linemodules via the plurality of switch modules, wherein the one or moreingress line modules receive fabric state information from the chassisout-of-band via the cabling, and wherein, responsive to congestion on apath through the plurality of switch modules, a new path is selected byan ingress line module for an Ethernet flow.

In a further embodiment, a chassis in a modular network elementconfigured for Ethernet path selection includes one or more switchmodules; one or more controllers; a midplane for communication betweenthe one or more switch modules and the one or more controllers; andcabling for communication to one or more ingress line modules and one ormore egress line modules, wherein the one or more ingress line modulesand the one or more egress line modules are located separate from thechassis and connected to the chassis via the cabling, wherein one ormore Ethernet flows are distributed from the one or more ingress linemodules to the one or more egress line modules via the plurality ofswitch modules, wherein the one or more ingress line modules receivefabric state information from the one or more controllers out-of-bandvia the cabling, and wherein, responsive to congestion on a path throughthe plurality of switch modules, a new path is selected by an ingressline module for an Ethernet flow.

In an embodiment, a modular network element includes a plurality of linemodules and zero or more switch modules in a chassis, wherein theplurality of line modules are located separate from the chassis andconnected to the chassis and/or to one another via cabling. A method ofmanaging a modular network element as a single entity includes operatinga management plane between the plurality of line modules and the zero ormore switch modules via one or more dedicated links in the cabling;managing the plurality of line modules and the zero or more switchmodules as a single network element utilizing a chassis managementprotocol over the management plane; and designating one of a controllerin the chassis and a processor in one of the plurality of line modulesoperating as a virtual controller as primary for the chassis managementprotocol.

The method can further include providing a virtual slot number for eachof the plurality of line modules, wherein the virtual slot number isutilized to differentiate the plurality of line modules. The virtualslot number can be automatically assigned based on a position sensor oneach of the plurality of line modules or through the chassis detecting aposition of each of the plurality of line modules. The management planecan operate over Universal Serial Bus (USB) pins and a 10 GigabitEthernet alternate mode which uses a subset of the USB pins. The USB canbe used to bridge a plurality of protocols in the management plane andto determine module presence, and wherein the 10 Gigabit Ethernet isutilized for Precision Time Protocol. The USB can be used for power,presence, primary arbitration, bidirectional status, health monitoring,configuration, initialization of data path, software download,interrupts, reset, LED control, I2C bridge, Universal AsynchronousReceiver-Transmitter (UART) bridge, SPI bridge, Pulse Width Modulation(PWM) bridge, General-Purpose Input/Output (GPIO) bridge, and PCIebridge

The method can further include communicating between the controller inthe chassis and circuitry on a line module for establishing the chassismanagement protocol on the line module. The method can further includeselecting a candidate clock in the chassis management protocol forsynchronization and timing distribution. The method can further includecontinually measuring delay over the cabling to adjust phase of thetiming distribution. The management plane can be operated over thecabling out-of-band from a data plane.

In another embodiment, a modular network element managed as a singleentity includes a plurality of line modules; and zero or more switchmodules in a chassis, wherein the plurality of line modules are locatedseparate from the chassis and from one another, and connected to thechassis and/or to one another via cabling, wherein a management plane isoperated between the plurality of line modules and the zero or moreswitch modules via one or more dedicated links in the cabling, whereinthe plurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules aremanaged as a single network element utilizing a chassis managementprotocol over the management plane, and one of a controller in thechassis and a processor in one of the plurality of line modulesoperating as a virtual controller is designated as primary for thechassis management protocol.

In a further embodiment, an apparatus configured to manage a modularnetwork element includes a processor and memory storing instructionsthat, when executed, cause the processor to operate a management planebetween the plurality of line modules and the zero or more switchmodules via one or more dedicated links in cabling between the pluralityof line modules and the zero or more switch modules; and manage theplurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules as asingle network element utilizing a chassis management protocol over themanagement plane, wherein the apparatus is designated as a primary inthe chassis management protocol, and the apparatus is physicallyseparate from at least one of the plurality of line modules and the zeroor more switches.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The present disclosure is illustrated and described herein withreference to the various drawings, in which like reference numbers areused to denote like system components/method steps, as appropriate, andin which:

FIG. 1 is a logical diagram of a modular network element architectureutilizing lineboxes and coreboxes to achieve system capacity between 3.6Tb/s to 80 Tb/s and beyond;

FIG. 2 is a logical diagram of connectivity between the lineboxes andthe coreboxes in different configurations of the modular network elementarchitecture of FIG. 1;

FIG. 3 is a block diagram of connectivity between the corebox,associated lineboxes, and an optional slave corebox;

FIG. 4 is a block diagram of data plane and control plane fabricconnectivity in the modular network element architecture;

FIG. 5 is a block diagram of chassis management for the corebox;

FIG. 6 is a block diagram of physical connectivity in the modularnetwork element architecture;

FIG. 7 is a block diagram of a rack with linebox carriers equippedtherein and with no lineboxes;

FIG. 8 is a block diagram of the rack with lineboxes in the lineboxcarriers;

FIG. 9 is a perspective diagram of the linebox slot carrier;

FIG. 10 is a bottom view of the linebox slot carrier;

FIG. 11 is a perspective diagram of a front view and rear view of a rackwith a corebox, four lineboxes in associated linebox carriers, and eightempty linebox carriers;

FIG. 12 is a front view diagram and a rear view diagram of the rack fromFIG. 11;

FIG. 13 is a perspective diagram of the corebox;

FIG. 14 is a block diagram of communication between the corebox and thelineboxes;

FIG. 15 is a logical diagram of Ethernet paths through the modularnetwork element architecture with and without congestion;

FIG. 16 is a logical diagram of Ethernet paths through the modularnetwork element architecture illustrating multicast;

FIG. 17 is a logical diagram of an Ethernet multi-path data flow throughthe modular network element architecture;

FIG. 18 is a logical diagram of a TDM multi-path data flow through themodular network element architecture;

FIG. 19 is a logical diagram of Ethernet flows;

FIG. 20 is a block diagram of modular network element architectureillustrating TDM over an Ethernet fabric;

FIG. 21 is a diagram of a single linebox interconnected to otherlineboxes and coreboxes in a self-expanding manner;

FIG. 22 is a front view of an example modular network elementarchitecture with different lineboxes and ports;

FIG. 23 is a network diagram of the lineboxes in a self-expanding meshwithout the corebox;

FIG. 24 is a front view of the modular network element architectureillustrating virtual slot numbers and position sensors;

FIG. 25 is a block diagram of an example implementation of a linebox;

FIG. 26 is a block diagram of a front view and a rear view of anotherimplementation of the corebox;

FIG. 27 is a diagram of a Twinax cable and connector;

FIG. 28 is a flowchart of a process of deploying a modular networkelement;

FIG. 29 is a flowchart of a process of Ethernet path selection in amodular network element; and

FIG. 30 is a flowchart of a process of managing a modular networkelement.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DISCLOSURE

The present disclosure relates to a modular network element architecturethat is a hybrid of the conventional chassis-based approach and thecompletely decentralized rack mounted unit approach. The modular networkelement architecture provides the value of integration from thechassis-based approach while offering the flexibility of thedecentralized rack mounted unit approach. Variously, network elementscan be implemented with the modular network element architecture forpacket, hybrid TDM/packet, optical, hybrid TDM/optical, hybridTDM/packet, hybrid optical/TDM/packet, and the like. Aspects of themodular network element architecture include modularity, stackability,and scalability; a control plane; a flexible faceplate size;decentralized power/cooling; an open backplane interface; etc. Themodular network element architecture is configured for longevity beyondmultiple generations of backplane or chipset designs. The modularnetwork element architecture provides the advantages of both thechassis-based approach and the rack mounted unit approach.

The modular network element architecture provides operators the abilityto stack and scale. The objective of the modular network elementarchitecture is to provide a single hardware platform that can addressvarious markets, applications, etc. That is, the modular network elementarchitecture can unify disparate platforms thus minimizing developmentcosts and efforts. Having a variable-pitch, variable bandwidth, variabledepth, variable power/cooling slot means that the modular networkelement architecture can offer one platform for many markets. Eachmarket has different needs for module size based on chipsets, faceplatecomponents, etc. For example, a hybrid TDM/packet market requiresfront-end OTN chipsets that are not required by packet-only markets.Another example, a packet-only market might have higher oversubscriptionratios and therefore require more faceplate area for more pluggableoptics.

Modular Network Element Architecture

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of a modular network element architecture 10utilizing lineboxes 12 and coreboxes 14 to achieve system capacitybetween 3.6 Tb/s to 80 Tb/s and beyond. The modular network elementarchitecture 10 is a hybrid between the chassis-based approach and therack mounted unit-based approach. Specifically, the modular networkelement architecture 10 includes one or more lineboxes 12 which are acombination of a rack mounted unit in part and a module in a chassis inpart. The lineboxes 12 are called “lineboxes” because of their hybridnature between line modules and pizza boxes. The lineboxes 12 can bevariable sized, are fully enclosed rack mounted modules similar to pizzaboxes, but are inserted into slot carriers in a rack which has dataconnectors (e.g., Twinax) and power connectors. The linebox 12 enablesflexibility, a low first-in cost, pay as you grow, a range of systemsizes, and are not constrained by slot pitch or slot power (as in achassis). Additional details are described herein for the linebox 12,but generally the linebox 12 has front access and provides switching atLayer 1 (TDM), Layer 2 (packet), etc. For example, the lineboxes 12 canbe 1-2U high while the corebox 14 can be 6-12U high. The lineboxes 12are a hybrid between a pizza box and a line module, e.g., a pizza boxwhich is inserted into a slot carrier which has a connector for data andpower. The corebox 14 is similar to a chassis, but only for switchmodules (SM) 16 and controller (CTM) modules 18.

At the lower end of capacity, e.g., 3.6 Tb/s to 7.2 Tb/s, the modularnetwork element architecture 10 can employ only one or two lineboxes 12.Advantageously, this avoids the need for a switch module (SM), backplanehardware, cables, power, etc. that is not needed at this capacity. Thecorebox 14 can be added when required to provide expansion, e.g., at19.2 Tb/s and above, and to provide an intermediate/center-stage switchfor the modular network element architecture 10. After more than onelinebox 12 is employed in the modular network element architecture 10,connectivity between the lineboxes 12 and possibly the corebox 14 isthrough the connectors on the associated slot carriers housing thelineboxes 12. The corebox 14 can support one to four switch modules 16,two controller modules 18, and an access panel 20. The modular networkelement architecture 10 can support upwards of 40 Tb/s in a single rack,as well as expand to multiple racks through interconnecting coreboxes 14such as in a multi-stage Clos switch.

FIG. 2 is a logical diagram of connectivity between the lineboxes 12 andthe coreboxes 14 in different configurations of the modular networkelement architecture 10. For illustration purposes, the modular networkelement architecture 10 is described with reference to packet switching.However, those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize the samehardware, interconnectivity, etc. could be used for TDM (OpticalTransport Network (OTN)) switching, Multiprotocol Label Switching(MPLS), Internet Protocol (IP) routing, etc. For example, a singlelinebox 12 can include 16 front access ports such as at 100 Gb/s each,i.e., 16×100 GbE (Gigabit Ethernet). Two such lineboxes 12 cancollectively support 32 front access ports (16×100 GbE×2) as well as16×100 G ports on the rear through the slot carrier. For example, thecorebox 14 can support 128×100 GbE for each switch module 16. With 8lineboxes 12 and 4 switch modules 16 in one corebox 14 for 12.8 Tb/s,each linebox 12 can connect 4×100 GbE to each switch module 16. With 64lineboxes 12 and 8 switch modules 16 in two coreboxes 14 for 102.4 Tb/s,each linebox 12 can connect 2×100 GbE to each switch module 16.

Comparison Metrics

Hardware platform can be compared based on metrics such as watts/Gb/s(power), volume/Gb/s (space), and cost/Gb/s (cost). For power, as aircooling is driven to its limits, fan power consumption become a higherpart of the total power and more power is required to bend airflow twiceversus front-to-back airflow. The modular network element architecture10 is an open fabric which allows using only a sufficient number offabric links for each application, requiring less power. Also, Twinaxhas lower insertion loss than PCB backplanes, thus requiring less powerper distance. The modular network element architecture 10 can include anoptimized power supply tuned to the specific load of a linebox 12. Asystem that fully utilizes its chipset is more power efficient than onethat underutilizes its chipset. With a fixed-pitch system, the faceplatearea is not always matched to the chipset.

If the power supplies are optimized for delivering only the powernecessary in the hardware that is present, the space and volume is less.The modular network element architecture 10 can be re-targeted to workin a shallow or deep chassis and is thus more volume efficient. For thecost, including high-rate optical modems into a fixed-pitch designrequires heat pipe cooling, the cost of backplanes is increasing, theup-front cost of developing proprietary dedicated hardware issignificant, etc. which lead to high costs with conventional approaches.These costs are all avoided in the modular network element architecture10. The modular network element architecture 10 also avoids the need fora significant number of pluggable optical transceivers which are spaceinefficient. Further, the modular network element architecture 10enables variable pitch enabling support for multiplemarkets/applications with one platform. That is, the modular networkelement architecture 10 is meant to address various markets/applicationsenabling a vendor efficiency.

Connectivity

FIG. 3 is a block diagram of connectivity between the corebox 14,associated lineboxes 12, and an optional slave corebox 14. FIG. 4 is ablock diagram of data plane and control plane fabric connectivity in themodular network element architecture 10. FIG. 5 is a block diagram ofchassis management for the corebox 14. FIG. 6 is a block diagram ofphysical connectivity in the modular network element architecture 10.

In FIG. 3, the master corebox 14 includes the switch modules 16, thecontroller modules 18, and the access panel 20. The access panel 20 caninclude various ports, indicators (e.g., Light Emitting Diodes (LEDs),etc.), and the like. The corebox 14 can also include fans 22 and powersupplies 24. The switch modules 16 include a 1×100 GbE fabric connectionto the controller modules 18 and a Universal Serial Bus (USB) connectionto the controller modules 18 (e.g., a Peripheral Component InterconnectExpress (PCIe) bridge). The control modules 18 can include variousconnections to the access panel 20, a USB connection (e.g., a SerialPeripheral Interface (SPI) bridge) to the fans 22, and a USB connection(e.g., Inter-Integrated Circuit (I2C) bridge) to the power supplies 24.External connectivity to the corebox 14 can include N×100 GbE fabriclinks from the lineboxes 12, a 2×USB connection from the lineboxes 12 orslave coreboxes 14, and a 2×10 GbE USB connection from the lineboxes 12or slave coreboxes 14.

The USB management functions in the master corebox 14 include power,presence, primary arbitration, bidirectional status, health monitoring,configuration, initialization of data path, software download,interrupts, reset, LED control, I2C bridge, Universal AsynchronousReceiver-Transmitter (UART) bridge, SPI bridge, Pulse Width Modulation(PWM) bridge, General-Purpose Input/Output (GPIO) bridge, and PCIebridge. The 10 GbE control fabric (USB alternate mode) can performfunctions related to fabric congestion state transport, timingdistribution (Synchronous Ethernet (SyncE) and Precision Time Protocol(PTP), direct communication between linebox 12 peers, statistics,external management network, etc. Note, in addition to lineboxes 12, themodular network element architecture 10 can include optical boxes (forDense Wavelength Division Multiplexing (DWDM)), serverboxes (for computeor storage resources), etc. For reference, the term linebox 12 is usedherein and the linebox 12 includes faceplate ports and circuitry forswitching (TDM, packet, etc.). However, the linebox 12 can be an opticalbox (for transceivers, modems, transponders, etc.), a serverbox, etc.

In FIG. 4, two example lineboxes 12 are illustrated connected to acorebox 14. The lineboxes 12 include an Ethernet switch 30, physical(PHY) interfaces 32 connected to the Ethernet switch 32, and a processor(CPU) 34. Again, the linebox 12 and corebox 14 are illustrated, forexample, with Ethernet switching, but those of skill in the art willrecognize other protocols are also contemplated such as OTN, optical,etc. The physical interfaces 32 can include 100 G or similar opticaltransceiver, providing 100 GbE. The corebox 14 similarly includesmultiple Ethernet switches 40 on the switch modules 16. The controllermodules 18 also include an Ethernet switch 42 and a processor 44. TheEthernet switches 30 on the lineboxes 12 are connected to the Ethernetswitches 40 on the switch modules 16 such as via 100 GbE links. Theprocessor 34 is connected to the Ethernet switches 42 such as via USB/10GbE.

The modular network element architecture 10 utilizes USB for themanagement plane based on a desire to use open interfaces for externalconnectivity rather than proprietary connectivity. That is, there is alot of software infrastructure around USB, USB is widely available inchipsets, etc. USB works in an alternate mode or bridges. In the USBalternate mode, a subset of USB pins is allocated to a completelydifferent serial protocol (10 GE in this example). So, this protocol isrunning parallel to the USB protocol, not on top of the USB protocol.The 10 GbE running in the alternate mode can be used for SyncE +PTPtiming distribution amongst other things. For USB bridges, there aredevices that bridge the following over the USB protocol: I2C, UART, SPI,PWM, PCIe, and GPIO. USB is a host:peripheral model. All transactionsare initiated by the Host (usually the controller module 18). Interruptsby a peripheral are achieved via polling by the host.

FIG. 5 illustrates a corebox midplane 50 and details of the controllermodule 18. The controller module 18 has the processor 44 which can bex86-based and the Ethernet switch 42 which can be 10 GbE. Also, thecontroller module 18 includes a timing module (TM), a chassis managementprotocol, a chassis GPIO database, and power. The controller module 18connects to the lineboxes 12 and other coreboxes 14 via the corebox PCBmidplane 50. Any x86 in the system (including x86′s on a linebox 12) canbecome primary or secondary for operating a high-level control plane(e.g., MPLS, Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM)), but notlow-level chassis management plane (e.g., the chassis managementprotocol, 10 Gbe switch, System GPIO Database, Fabric Management PCIe,etc.). Primary control for the Chassis Management Plane is restricted tothe controller modules 18.

The primary controller module 18 provides 12V power to a small FieldProgrammable Gate Array (FPGA) or other circuitry on each linebox 12 forthe purpose of establishing the Chassis Control Plane that can powerlinebox 12 on and off. Any linebox 12 can provide candidate timing; theprimary controller module 18 chooses one candidate clock to synchronizeits own TM block, which then distributes that timing to all lineboxes.The chassis management protocol includes the establishment of a two-wayprotocol to indicate linebox 12 presence. The primary controller module18 receives GPIO from all lineboxes 12 and periodically broadcasts thechassis GPIO database to all lineboxes 12. This achieves reset,interrupt, primary-ship request, primary-ship grant, etc. The protocolcan have a fixed superframe size that allows accuratetransmission/reception of ToD/1 pps/8 kHz to all the lineboxes. Also,each linebox 12 can display its virtual slot number on its faceplate.

In FIG. 6, an example physical connectivity is illustrated with a sideview, a front view, and a rear view of the modular network elementarchitecture 10. The modular network element architecture 10 supportsmounting in a 19″ (or 23″) rack and FIG. 6 does not show the rack. Thecorebox 14 can have a depth of about 450mm. The switch modules 16, thecontroller modules 18, and the access panel 20 do not need a large deptheven after factoring the bend radius of a Twinax bundle (about 0.6″).The linebox 12 can have different depths, e.g., 450-1000 mm depending onthe application. The lineboxes 12 can be targeted at different sizessince they do not have to work into legacy constraints for size, power,cooling, and connectivity. The modular network element architecture 10supports front to back airflow.

The example of FIG. 6 includes the corebox 14 with 6 possible switchmodules 16, with only 3 shown equipped. A few different types oflineboxes 12 are shown include an X86 serverbox which provides computeresources, a 36×100 G linebox for extra faceplate ports (e.g., doubleheight), a 16×100 G linebox (e.g., single height, but extra depth), afiber deep linebox (e.g., double height, extra depth), etc.

The corebox 14 includes a midplane 50 which interconnects the switchmodules 16, the controller modules 18, the access panel 20, etc. Thecorebox 14 can connect to the lineboxes 12 via Twinax connectors 52which are cabled from the rear of the corebox 14 to linebox carrierswhich are described in additional detail herein. In the rear view ofFIG. 6, the lineboxes 12 can have one, two, or more Twinax connectors52. For example, double height lineboxes 12 can have two Twinaxconnectors 52, single height lineboxes 12 can have one Twinax connector52, etc. The corebox 14 can have a Twinax connector field 54 which iscabled to each of the linebox carriers and a control plane connectorfield 56. For example, each Twinax connector 52 can have 36 data planelinks which are split into 3×12 links to the Twinax connector field 54.Of course, other implementations are also contemplated. The Twinaxconnector 52 can plug directly into an Ortho-Direct (from Molex), PCBbackplane, or cabled backplane.

The present disclosure utilizes the term “Twinax” for the Twinaxconnector 52 and the Twinax connector field 54. Those skilled in the artrecognize this can also include Twinaxial or any other type ofelectrical cabling such as coaxial cabling. That is, the electricalcabling can have any type of implementation.

Compatibility with Operations, Administration, Maintenance, andProvisioning (OAM&P)

The lineboxes 12 and the corebox 14 can implement a scalable chassiscontrol plane with a multiplexed protocol, the ability to add x86servers to the control plane, and the ability to elect primary-ownershipoutside of the corebox 14 in a linebox 12 only implementation. Of note,the modular network element architecture 10 is a hybrid between achassis-based implementation and a pizza box-based implementation.However, operations for OAM&P is used for chassis-based management.Accordingly, the modular network element architecture 10 can beconfigured to emulate an existing chassis from a software perspective.For example, the modular network element architecture 10 includes aconcept of a virtual slot number to assist operations personnel withlocating the lineboxes 12 in a physical rack. In an embodiment, themodular network element architecture 10 can use a position sensor suchas an altimeter on each linebox 12 for the purpose of establishing amonotonic virtual slot number series in the rack. This provides a uniquedetermination of physical slot numbers that allows employing slots ofdifferent physical sizes, a way of sorting slot numbers based on theposition sensor, and use of a display to show slot number.

As described herein, the scalable chassis control plane can use USBalongside a 10 GbE alternate mode for the purpose of flexible chassismanagement (primary ownership, remote powering, presence, status, healthmonitoring, configuration, software download, interrupts, reset, LEDcontrol, protocol bridges, etc.).

The chassis control plane can include the unbundling ofprimary-ownership: multiple primary-ownerships depending on box type andfunction (i.e., not limited to a corebox 14). The chassis control planeincludes the ability to distribute multiple clock domains over a singlelink, remote powering allows a linebox 12 to be managed that does nothave main power, ability to measure round-trip cable time for purpose ofadjusting clock phase for each box, the ability to upgrade cabledbackplane (one cable at a time) without hitting the chassis controlplane, the ability of the corebox 14 to power-cycle remote lineboxes 12or communicate with them when only their control circuitry is powered,and the ability of linebox 12 to power up without a corebox 14 instandalone or mesh configurations as part of the negotiation process.

In a rack with lineboxes 12, it is not immediately apparent how thechassis control plane should be implemented especially if it needs toemulate an existing chassis from a software perspective. It also needsto deal with N:1 redundancy, lineboxes 12 that can manage the wholechassis (standalone and mesh configurations), reduce number of links tosimplify cable management, and the ability to extend the control planeto server boxes.

In the past, common practice used to be “1 pin per signal” for varioussignals. Historically this was due to the relative expense of SERDEScapacity relative to backplane pins. This has shifted recently andallows for much greater multiplexing of many signals onto one SERDESlink. Therefore, the chassis management protocol link carries Time ofDay (ToD), 1 pps, 8 kHz, GPIO, presence, status, interrupts, reset,primary-ownership, etc.

The chassis management protocol is two-way between lineboxes 12,coreboxes 14, etc. and the establishment thereof between two devices isused to indicate box presence. A primary controller 18 receives GPIOfrom all lineboxes 12 and periodically broadcasts the chassis GPIOdatabase to all lineboxes 12. This achieves reset, interrupt,primary-ownership request, primary-ownership grant, virtual slot number,etc. The protocol has a fixed superframe size that allows accuratetransmission/reception of ToD/1 pps/8 kHz to all lineboxes 12; 25 Mhzdistribution uses a dedicated link.

After a successful negotiation, any x86 in the system (including x86′son a linebox 12, i.e., the processor 34) can become primary or secondaryfor the chassis control plane (e.g., MPLS graceful restart, OAM), butnot low-level chassis management plane (e.g., chassis managementprotocol, 10 Gbe switch, System GPIO Database, Fabric Management).Negotiation is based on memory and processing capacities dependent oncurrently configured functions and reserved capacities.Primary-ownership for the chassis management plane is restricted tocontrollers 18 on the corebox 14 when present in the interconnectedmodular network element architecture 10.

The primary controller 18 provides 12V power to a small FPGA on eachlinebox 12 and serverbox for the purpose of establishing the chassiscontrol plane that can power boxes on and off, hold in reset, etc. AnyBox can provide candidate timing; the primary controller 18 chooses onecandidate clock to synchronize its own timing module 104 block, whichthen distributes that timing to all boxes. Multiple clock domains can bedistributed by sending frequency and 1pps offsets relative to the mainsuperframe phase and the single 25 Mhz clock link. This enables multipletiming domains to be distributed within a single chassis if necessary.

As part of chassis management protocol, round-trip delay measurement isemployed for the purpose of measuring backplane cable length. This isused to adjust the phase of timing distribution to each linebox 12. Thisis a continuous process which adapts if a backplane cable is replaced.

USB is generally used to connect peripherals but using USB alongside its10 GE alternate mode to manage a chassis is proposed in the modularnetwork architecture 10; especially the use of USB in a multiple mastermode with primary ownership negotiation. The functional partitioningbetween USB and 10 GE alternate mode and how they work together isproposed and offers improved implementation. For example, USB powerdelivery is chosen rather than PoE (Power Over Ethernet). Likewise,Module Presence is provided via USB rather than Ethernet. USB is alsoused to bridge various protocols such as I2C, UART, SPI, PWM, and PCIe.However, SyncE and PTP timing are distributed over Ethernet rather thanUSB.

Linebox Carriers

FIG. 7 is a block diagram of a rack 60 with linebox carriers 70 equippedtherein and with no lineboxes 12. FIG. 8 is a block diagram of the rack60 with lineboxes 12 in the linebox carriers 70. The rack 60 can be astandard telecom/Datacom 19″ rack with a rail 62 on each side. The rail62 can be a C-channel rail (C being the shape of the rail). The lineboxcarriers 70 can be an all-metal structure for physically supporting anassociated linebox 12 and the Twinax connector 52 and a power connector64. The linebox slot carrier 70 has no PCB or electronics thereon (otherthan the connectors 52, 64), i.e., the linebox slot carrier 70 ispassive. In an embodiment, the linebox slot carrier 70 includesretractable pins 72 which lock the linebox slot carrier 70 into place inthe rail 62. The Twinax connector 52 is held in a fixed position at therear of the linebox slot carrier 70. The linebox carriers 70 can bemoved up and down in the rack 60 (also known as a frame) and cabling 74connected to the linebox carriers 70 includes slack allowing for thelinebox slot carrier 70 to be moved vertically by multiple Rack Units(U). The cabling 74 connects to the corebox 14.

In FIG. 8, example lineboxes 12 are shown placed in the linebox carriers70. The linebox 12 slides horizontally (front-to-back) into the lineboxcarrier 70. The linebox carrier 70′s primary function is to provide afixed location for the Twinax connector 52 to allow insertion of alinebox 12 without requiring rear access. The cable lengths can befactory-configured to suit customer's specific configuration of linebox12 sizes.

A common carrier design for the linebox slot carrier 70 can be appliedin variants dependent on the requirements of different lineboxes 12.FIG. 8 illustrates four example variations of the linebox slot carrier70A, 70B, 70C, 70D. A linebox slot carrier 70A includes one Twinaxconnector 52 and one power connector 64, and can be used to support asingle or double height linebox 12. A linebox slot carrier 70B includestwo Twinax connectors 52 and one power connector 64 in the middle. Thelinebox slot carrier 70B supports half-sized lineboxes 12. A lineboxslot carrier 70C includes two Twinax connectors 52 and two powerconnector 64 to support a larger height linebox 12. Finally, a lineboxslot carrier 70D includes no Twinax connectors 52 and one powerconnector 64 such as for an optical box or the like which does not needfabric plane connectivity to the corebox 14.

FIG. 9 is a perspective diagram of the linebox slot carrier 70 and FIG.10 is a bottom view of the linebox slot carrier 70. The linebox slotcarrier 70 includes the retractable pins 72 which can include aspring-loaded mechanism that grabs into holes in the rail 62 and has a“push to disengage” feature which avoids the need for side or rearaccess. For example, a latch 76 can be pulled to disengage the pins 72so that the linebox slot carrier 70 can be moved up and down.

Variable Pitch Backplane Virtual Slots

With the lineboxes 12 in the modular network element architecture 10with cabled backplane connections, one can take advantage of theirphysical flexibility to create the slot carriers 70 populated withlineboxes 12 whose position can shift within a range. This allowslinebox 12 modules of different faceplate heights to be stacked togetherin a chassis without wasting fabric capacity.

The modular network element architecture 10 allows the customer toretain the ability to replace a linebox 12 without having to go to theback of the chassis to disconnect/reconnect fabric cables. A cablereceptacle (the connectors 52, 64) is attached to the slot carrier 70and the slot carrier 70 can slide vertically on the chassis within arange (e.g., up to 4 U) provided by extra slack in the backplanecabling. A vertical physical guide mechanism (e.g. C-channel in the rail62) can provide the sliding rail on the chassis for the slot carriers 70and holes to lock in various slot carrier positions on a 1 Ugranularity. The slot carrier 70 has pins 72 that can be depressed tomove it up or down and then lock into the C-channel's holes—all whilethe backplane cable is still attached. The slot carrier 70 also providesstandard header alignment mechanisms to allow a linebox 12 module toplug into the slot carrier 70. The slot carriers 70 themselves do notneed to be moved by the customer to provide value—factoryconfigurability allows unique slot size configurations to suit a givencustomer. A customer can modify slot positions themselves based on howmuch cable slack was built in.

The slot carrier 70 can have multiple positions for separate cablebundles. Not all cable bundles need to be populated, which allows thelinebox 12 to be given the amount of fabric bandwidth it needs withoutwasting fabric bandwidth as per conventional PCB backplane systems.

Rack View

FIG. 11 is a perspective diagram of a front view and rear view of a rack60 with a corebox 14, four lineboxes 12 in associated linebox carriers70, and eight empty linebox carriers 70. FIG. 12 is a front view diagramand a rear view diagram of the rack 60 from FIG. 11. FIG. 13 is aperspective diagram of the corebox 14.

The modular network element architecture 10 can be deployed in a varietyof configurations with lineboxes 12 and optionally with the corebox 14as a centralized chassis with cable subtended to the lineboxes 12 in thesame rack 60 or different rack. The corebox 14 can include modules forthe switch modules 16, controller 18, timing, etc. which can be linkedvia the midplane 50 in the corebox 14.

The switch modules 16 can connect to the lineboxes 12 as describedherein via electrical or optical cabling at the rear of the rack 60 andthe front of the rack 60 is used for customer-facing interfaces. Asdescribed herein, the rear cables are separated into bundles that matchthe fabric module granularity. The control plane signals can be in thesame cable bundle or a physically separate cable bundle from the fabriccables. The control plane cable bundle includes a multiplexed protocolthat signals ToD/1 pps/frequency, presence, status, primary ownership,interrupts, reset, position identification, Ethernet, and power.

The corebox 14 can power a subset of control circuitry on the lineboxes12. Different redundancy ratios are supported for different functionssuch as local Ethernet Fabric (N:1), Timing Distribution (1:1), Chassismanagement (1:1), and MPLS Control Plane (N:1) and a switchover of onefunction does not force a switchover of the other function, and eachfunction can reside on different modules. The access panel 20 for themodular network element architecture 10 is centralized in the corebox 14and can serve all lineboxes 12 in such a Switch System. Advantageously,cooling of the corebox 14 and the lineboxes 12 is independent from oneanother and airflow is significantly improved.

The modular network element architecture 10 includes physically separatedevices (lineboxes 12 and the corebox 14), but it is managed as a singleentity, e.g., alarms, statistics, Performance Monitoring (PM) data, etc.are aggregated and the modular network element architecture 10 is asingle network element. When the corebox 14 is omitted, a single linebox12 can virtualize the corebox 14 management functions such as thecontrol plane and fabric management.

Ethernet Fabric

Various existing solutions hash an Ethernet flow to a specific path thatexists for the lifetime of the flow, such as Link Aggregation, forexample. In Ethernet fabrics, a slow control plane routes new flows awayfrom congested hot-spots when elephant flows cause hot spots andunbalance the fabrics, but this is a slow process which results incongestion aliasing. An elephant flow is an extremely large (in totalbytes) continuous flow over a network link. Elephant flows, though notnumerous, can occupy a disproportionate share of the total bandwidthover a period of time. The conventional approach is to break up elephantflows at their natural gaps in order to move links without causingmisordering. Of course, the conventional approach cannot break up anelephant flow unless the elephant flow already has gaps.

Further, the conventional approach estimates path latency based onbuffer fill levels, but this is not as accurate as a timestampedapproach with out-of-band timing distribution. Also, the conventionalapproach does not utilize TDM for the purpose of improving data trafficin an Ethernet Fabric. To that end, the modular network elementarchitecture 10 requires new approaches in terms of the Ethernet fabric.

In various embodiments, an Ethernet fabric in the modular networkelement architecture 10 can create gaps in large continuous Elephantflows by artificially forcing momentary buffering such that the gap isno larger than the path delay difference between the current path and anew path. This allows a single flow to be spread over many links andtherefore improves Ethernet Fabric utilization. The modular networkelement architecture 10 can also include the addition of post-bufferingand shaping to OTN segmentation to create evenly-spaced mice flows forthe purpose of improving Ethernet Fabric utilization (a mouse flow isthe opposite of an elephant flow).

The modular network element architecture 10 uses out-of-band timingdistribution coupled with TDM Segmentation and Reassembly (SAR) tomeasure fabric latency on all paths. The modular network elementarchitecture 10 can spread TDM across paths evenly for the purpose ofmeasuring all paths through the fabric without introducing probepackets. Specifically, the TDM packet SAR header (sequence number) isused to estimate relative path latency deltas and this is fed into apath selection algorithm. The out-of-band congestion notificationdistribution is used over the cabled backplane to estimate path delaytolerant of high congestion, which is when path delay needs to be mostaccurate. The out-of-band path selection broadcast allows every linebox12 to build a global path selection state for the purpose of preventingflapping when flows are moved away from congested links.

The TDM SAR is used to actively balance an Ethernet fabric whose dataflows are resulting in an unbalanced fabric. The path selectionalgorithm has unique rules for unicast, multicast, and TDM flows.Together with the above, restricting the top Class of Service (CoS) toTDM-only, undershaping traffic is proposed for the purpose of fabricspeedup to keep latency within a target range. Path flapping isprevented by communicating path selection status between lineboxes 12for the purpose of preventing multiple lineboxes 12 from moving largeflows to the same link, causing congestion, and all moving flows back,and repeating the cycle. Use of hash to make common decisions aboutwhich flows get to move.

FIG. 14 is a block diagram of communication between the corebox 14 andthe lineboxes 12. The communication is through a control plane using a10 Gbe or 100 GbE link. The corebox 14 maintains a system database ofpath state (such as congestion status, path reservation status, etc.).It is an event-driven publish/subscribe model. This allows a linebox 12to make a path selection decision based on the global system state inthe modular network element architecture 10 and scheduled path selectionfrom other lineboxes 12 rather than just its local state. Negotiatedpath selection based on the global state prevents path flapping wherebyall lineboxes 12 move a large flow onto an empty link, congest it, andmove their flows away from that link again, etc. The fabric congestionstate and the linebox path selection state are transported out-of-band.

FIG. 15 is a logical diagram of Ethernet paths through the modularnetwork element architecture 10 with and without congestion. In thisexample, there is three ingress lineboxes 12A, 12B, 12C, a corebox 14,and one egress linebox 12D. The ingress lineboxes 12A, 12B, 12C eachconnect to one switch module 16 at 100 G in the corebox 14 as does theegress linebox 12D. At the top portion of FIG. 15, the ingress lineboxes12A, 12C each provides a flow to the first switch module 16, resultingin congestion on the link between the switch module 16 and the egresslinebox 12D. At the bottom portion of FIG. 15, the ingress linebox 12Cselects a new path thereby alleviating the congestion.

FIG. 16 is a logical diagram of Ethernet paths through the modularnetwork element architecture 10 illustrating multicast. In this example,there is one ingress linebox 12 and two egress lineboxes 12 with thecorebox 14 in-between. There are three Link Aggregation Groups (LAGs)LAG1, LAG2, LAG3 between the ingress linebox 12 and the switch modules16 in the corebox 14. There are two LAGs, LAG4, LAG5 between the firstswitch module 16 and the egress lineboxes 12. TDM protection requires1:N multicast (MC) where N≤4. For an MC replicant flow, a local FabricElement (FE) performs the load balancing function on the linebox 12,corebox 14, etc. One replicant might see congestion and the other mightnot. The congested replicant cannot move to a different fabric elementbecause that would require the MC to happen at the ingress linebox 12and could lead to Fabric Input Blocking. If all members of LAGS arecongested, then the pre-replicant flow must be moved to a differentFabric Element where both replicant paths are uncongested. This decisionis made by the ingress linebox 12 based on corebox 14 congestion state.

FIG. 17 is a logical diagram of an Ethernet multi-path data flow throughthe modular network element architecture 10. FIG. 17 illustrates packetson a 100 GbE ingress port, a flow A which is 40 Gb/s, and a flow B whichis 60 Gb/s, both of the flows A, B are elephant flows which can causepoor load-balancing and therefore poor fabric utilization (some linkscongested and others underutilized). There are interburst gaps andflowbursts for each of the flows A, B, and there can be two paths 1, 2in the modular network element architecture 10 with a latency of 500 ns,600 ns, respectively. The modular network element architecture 10 caninclude sending the different flowbursts on the different paths to avoidcongestion and underutilization. As described herein, a flowburst ispart of a flow, such as an elephant flow, between interburst gaps. Also,each flowburst can take a different path in the fabric as describedherein.

FIG. 18 is a logical diagram of a TDM multi-path data flow through themodular network element architecture 10. Note, an Optical Data Unitlevel 4 (ODU4) does not fit in a 100 GbE and even if it did, it would bean elephant flow that unbalances the fabric. Accordingly, TDM mice flowsare spread across all fabric links as shown in FIG. 18 on six examplepaths. Fragments on different paths can arrive out of order, so they aregiven sequence numbers and buffered/reassembled in order. By breakingODU4 into many mice flow fragments, bandwidth is spread evenly acrossall fabric paths which results in good fabric utilization. TDM fragmentscarry timestamps that allow measurement of path latency on all paths tobe continuously measured.

Forced Gaps on Elephant Flows

FIG. 19 is a logical diagram of Ethernet flows. First, a single elephantflow is shown on the faceplate 100 GbE port, i.e., with no gaps betweenpackets. The problem is this flow would normally want to stay on asingle fabric link to prevent re-ordering. The fabric might have 150Gb/s of bandwidth available, but that bandwidth might be spread over 15fabric links, so a given link only has 10 Gb/s of bandwidth available.The Elephant Flow does not fit anywhere and causes congestion regardlessof which link it is put on.

Next, the elephant flow is broken up into two bursts. The ingresslinebox 12 circuitry (e.g., FPGA) temporarily buffers the elephant flowand introduces a forced gap. This gap allows the ingress Ethernet switchto send the first burst on link #1, the second burst on link #2, thethird burst on link #3, etc. This allows the elephant flow to be spreadinto the available bandwidth on many fabric links and therefore achievehigher fabric utilization.

The forced gap is not a static value. The size of the gap is determinedby the difference in latency between the previous path and the newcandidate path. If the candidate path is higher latency, then no gapneeds to be introduced. But the path selection algorithm would normallytry to find lower latency paths where possible. In those cases where thecandidate path is lower latency,Forced_Gap_size=Latency_old_path—Latency_candidate_path+margin. Note,this process does not increase the latency of the original flow relativeto the latency of the original path.

The bottom two flows in FIG. 19 illustrate fabric links #1, #2 whichhandle the different bursts created by the forced gap. Note, the forcedgap in the elephant flow does not waste bandwidth because the ingressEthernet switch fills the gaps with other flows. In a combined TDM/Dataapplication, TDM generates lots of 512 B mice flows that can easily fillin the gaps. Also, elephant flows only need to be broken up if there isnot a sufficiently large and contiguous bandwidth block on a fabric linkor if they do not have natural gaps. Therefore, gap forcing in elephantflows can be dependent on congestion, fabric contiguous bandwidth, etc.

Path Selection

By default, the path selection can be static at startup or at theaddition of a new linebox 12 through a static mapping of ingress portsto egress ports. This approach for the linebox 12 spreads ingress portsevenly over all available fabrics and fabric links, and for the corebox14 spreads all ingress ports evenly within each linebox 12 trunk. Afterthis static configuration and depending on traffic flow, there can becongestion so the paths must be modified dynamically by the pathselection algorithm.

The path selection algorithm is implemented in the modular networkelement architecture 10 and includes monitored metrics. Specifically,for each ingress flow, a counter is maintained that measures the mostrecent Interburst Gap and flow bandwidth. Also, the measure of pathlatency is maintained for every path (between lineboxes 12, corebox 14).Since TDM fragments are spread over all paths, it is possible to usetheir timestamps to continuously estimate latency on all paths. If noTDM is present, internal Delay Measurement Messages (DMNIs) can begenerated for this purpose. An exponential moving average can be used tosmooth the latency estimates.

Again, the corebox 14 provides out-of-band communication of fabriccongestion states to all ingress lineboxes 12. Specifically, thisexchange is not in-band since congestion state packets could be affectedby the congestion they are trying to report. Also, out-of-bandcommunication of the path selection state is broadcast by all lineboxes12.

The flowbursts define the path selection granularity. A flowburst iseligible to follow a different path from the previous flowburst if itsinterburst gap is larger than the difference in latency between existingpath (high latency) and new path (low latency). This allows flows to bemoved dynamically (rather than static hash-based load balancing).

For dynamic path selection and manual override, flows can be movedmanually without introducing packet re-ordering. This is done byintentionally pausing the flow and allowing it to buffer up until anartificial interburst gap is created, which allows the flow to be movedautomatically by the path selection algorithm or manually.

The linebox 12 makes the path selections based on congestion estimatesof the whole path. It can choose a new path inside or outside of a LAGtrunk. The corebox 14 makes path selections only within a LAG trunk.Unreachable paths are not used. This can be due to faulty links, missingfabrics, etc.

For a unicast flow, every time a new flow starts or there is asufficiently large flow burstgap, then a new path with least latency ischosen. The delta in latency between the old path and a new path must beover a threshold for the flow to be moved to prevent unnecessarymovement for negligible gains.

The local Fabric Element on the linebox 12 performs the load balancingfunction for each LAG for both unicast and multicast. But for multicast,it is possible that all members of a given fabric LAG are congested, sothe pre-replicant flow must be moved to a different Fabric Element thathas uncongested LAG's. This decision is made by the ingress linebox 12based on corebox 14 congestion state. Note, replicant flows arerestricted from being on different Fabric Elements because that wouldrequire MC at the ingress linebox 12 which could lead to Fabric InputBlocking.

For TDM, the OTN over Packet Fabric Protocol (OFP) ImplementationAgreement (November 2011) from the Optical Internetworking Forum, thecontents of which are incorporated by reference, can be used. Here, TDMis broken up into many small flows that require a SAR function toreassemble in the correct order. TDM flows can be moved at will withoutconcern for packet ordering because the SAR will take care of correctingthe order. The path selection algorithm is aware of TDM and non-TDMflows; The TDM flows are exempt from the interburst gap path selectionrequirements. In the case that the fabric is unaware of the flow type,the SAR function can add post-buffering to create evenly spacedinterburst gaps to the TDM flow.

For path flapping, a given linebox 12 has a view of the FabricCongestion state, but it does not have a view of what the other linebox12's are doing. Two lineboxes 12 could make the simultaneous decision tomove a flow to an uncongested link and thereby cause it to becomecongested. Both lineboxes 12 could then move their flows away leading toflapping. Each linebox 12 broadcasts its Path Selection State to theother lineboxes 12 (and corebox 14) so that all can build a view of theGlobal Path Table. For all the flows on a congested link, the flow withthe highest hash is the only one moved away during the currentcongestion interval.

TDM over Ethernet Fabric

FIG. 20 is a block diagram of modular network element architecture 10illustrating TDM over an Ethernet fabric. Specifically, there is aningress linebox 12A, the corebox 14, and the egress linebox 12B. Thelineboxes 12A, 12B include OTN circuitry 100 for OTN framing,Serializing/Deserializing (SERDES), switching, mapping, etc. The OTNcircuitry 100 can support up to 50 μs of latency, but the Ethernetswitches 30, 40 have far less latency variation. The OTN circuity 100connects to an Interlaken (ILKN) FPGA 102 which connects to the Ethernetswitch 30. The corebox 14 can include a timing module 104 which iscommunicatively coupled to the OTN circuitry 100 and the ILKN FPGA 102.

For TDM over Ethernet, the corebox 14 Ethernet switches 40 can turn offswitch features such as MLAG, Storm Control, Ingress Access ControlLists (ACLs), port mirroring, etc. in order to bypass pipeline blocksand provide cut-through forwarding. The path selection can be configuredto reduce utilization on links that have TDM.

The timing module 104 provides a mechanism for transferring the timinginformation of Optical Data Unit level k (ODUk)/Optical Data Unit flex(ODUflex) client signals across a packet fabric such that ITU-TRecommendation G.8251 timing specifications are still met without areduction in the maximum number of network elements allowed by theG.8251 Hypothetical Reference Model. The timing module 104 transfers thetiming information of ODUk/ODUflex client signals across a packet fabricthat is agnostic to fabric latency and latency variations. The timingmodule 104 can be used to compensate the packet fabric latency to aconfigurable value (max fabric latency≤config value≤100 μs) with aresolution of better than 5 ns. ITU-T Recommendation G.8251 “The controlof jitter and wander within the optical transport network (OTN)” (09/10)is incorporated herein by reference.

Linebox Self-Expanding System

FIG. 21 is a diagram of a single linebox 12 interconnected to otherlineboxes 12 and coreboxes 14 in a self-expanding manner. Each linebox12 can include one or more Fabric Access Processors (FAP) and FabricElement (FE) (available from Broadcom). The FAP and FE are circuitry forEthernet switching. The number of FAP-to-FE links changes every time alinebox 12 is added. A subset of cables is simply moved (in-service). Ifthe cable/connector granularity is 3 links, then 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, and12-Box systems can be supported with one cable.

Linebox Ports

FIG. 22 is a front view of an example modular network elementarchitecture 10 with different lineboxes 12A, 12B, 12C and ports. Forexample, the linebox 12A is a half-sized module with optical modems,e.g., an optical box supporting high-speed optical transceivers for DWDMtransmission. The linebox 12B is a large, double-height modulesupporting 96× Small Form Factor plus (SPF+) pluggable modules (10Gb/s). The linebox 12C is a half-sized module supporting 32× Quad SmallForm Pluggable 28 (QSFP28) pluggable modules (4×28 Gb/s). The lineboxes12 can support different oversubscription ratios depending on customerneeds, have different ratios of SFP+versus QSFP28, can configuredifferent ratios of ports with and without Media Access Control Security(MACSec) or OTN, can include x86 fabric-connected half-width servers asper customer needs, etc. The lineboxes 12 can be used with the corebox14 to provide redundancy, larger switch, timing distribution, etc.

Linebox Self-Expanding Mesh

FIG. 23 is a network diagram of the lineboxes 12 in a self-expandingmesh without the corebox 14. Each linebox 12 contains the Ethernetswitch 30 which can perform two functions—fabric connectivity andaggregation of low-speed interfaces (e.g., 10 Gb/s or 100 Gb/s ports) toa 400 GbE fabric. In FIG. 23, the any-to-any switch configuration isshown in dotted lines and the edge aggregation configuration is shown insolid lines. Also, each linebox 12 has a processor 34 which can act as avirtual controller 18 for the entire system.

The modular network element architecture 10 has the flexibility andadvantage of expansion with only lineboxes 12 and/or with the corebox14. As shown in FIG. 21, the linebox 12 can include FAPs and an FE. Thecorebox 14 can also include multiple FEs. Note, this is similar to thestructure used in existing chassis-based systems, e.g., FAPs on linemodules and FEs on switch modules.

In FIG. 21, a system can include only lineboxes 12 where the fabric isdistributed in each linebox 12 rather than in a centralized corebox 14.This can serve various applications. Again, the linebox 12 includes theprocessor 34 which can instantiate a virtualized controller module 18function and can therefore manage the whole chassis. The linebox 12 cancommunicate with other lineboxes 12 to arbitrate for primary ownership.

The primary linebox 12 is configured to distribute timingsynchronization to all the other lineboxes 12, reflect presenceinformation to all lineboxes 12, etc. The primary linebox 12 can acceptinterrupts and status from all other lineboxes 12. The primary linebox12 can provide power to a subset of control circuitry in the otherlineboxes 12 similar to as described herein with respect to the corebox14. The primary linebox 12 acts as a central control plane Ethernetswitch, a central GPIO reflector, etc.

For example, each linebox 12 can contain 2 FAP devices and 1 FE device.The FAPs are connected to the local FE through a PCB or cabled links inthe linebox 12 and meshed to all the other linebox 12 FEs via the cabledbackplane. The unused SERDES on each FE can be made available to otherlineboxes 12 that contain FAPs allowing the self-expansion.

In a system with a single linebox 12, a loopback cable can connect theFAPs fully to the local FE within the same linebox 12. The backplanecable granularity can support 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, and/or 12 linebox 12 sizedsystems. Also, the system supports the in-service hitless addition of anew linebox 12 to a self-expanded linebox 12 system. A procedure to moveone cable at a time can be enforced by a locking cable assemblycontrolled by detection of operational fabric links such that a newcable cannot be removed until both ends of the previous cable arecorrectly seated.

The corebox 14 can also be incorporated in the self-expanded linebox 12system to increase the range of expansion, add redundancy, or timingdistribution. Thus, the modular network element architecture 10 includesthe ability to mix self-expanding systems with central fabrics.

The factory configurable fabric connectivity can be optimized forany-to-any switching and for aggregation topology switch. The in-servicehitless expansion is enabled by link-up detection controlling aconnector locking mechanism. The cable granularity allows multipleexpansion ranges with the fewest number of cables.

Slot Numbering

In a conventional chassis, the slot number is well known, i.e., whichnumbered slot a module is inserted into. With the modular networkelement architecture 10, the concept of “physical slot number” isreplaced with a “virtual slot number,” which can be associated to thenumbered cable connectors on the corebox 14 midplane 50. Physical andvirtual slot numbers are not necessarily mapped 1:1 because a linebox 12might be 1 U, 2 U, or 4 U and still be considered as a single virtualslot even though it can occupy a range of physical fixed-slot positionsin a rack. A technician who needs to replace “linebox virtual slot 3”needs some way of identifying the physical position of that linebox 12within the rack. This is achieved by a small display on each linebox 12that displays the virtual slot number.

It is generally suggested that linebox 12 be plugged into cablessequentially which results in monotonic virtual slot number series.However, there are cases where this might not be the case and lineboxes12 will have out of order virtual slot numbers. In these cases, asolution is proposed so that the technician does not need to search upand down the rack for a particular virtual slot number: a linebox 12 canbe given its virtual slot number based on its local altimeter sensor anda continuous calibration involving known-position altimeter sensors, forexample, within the corebox 14.

FIG. 24 is a front view of the modular network element architecture 10illustrating virtual slot numbers 150 and position sensors 152. Thevirtual slot numbers 150 can be a display which provides a number orother unique identifier. The display is illustrated in the top leftportion of the faceplate, but those of ordinary skill recognize apractical implementation can be anywhere. The position sensor 152 isused to automatically identify a location for purposes of assigning thevirtual slot numbers 150. In some embodiments, the position sensor 152can be a physical device, and in other embodiments, the position sensor152 can be a technique.

In an embodiment, a set of coded active transmitters can be attached tothe rack 60 in predetermined positions. The lineboxes 12 and the corebox14 can lock to the code and measure received power level as well astimestamp the signal from each active transmitter. The lineboxes 12 cancommunicate their measured power and timestamp data to the corebox 14 orthe linebox 12 which uses a relative comparison of all the data todetermine the relative position of each linebox 12. The relativeposition is then communicated to each lineboxes 12 through the datafabric. Determination of relative position between lineboxes 12 is moreaccurate than the determination of absolute position.

As described herein, the lineboxes 12 are phase and frequencysynchronized to the corebox 14 via dedicated point-to-point cabledconnection (sub-nanosecond absolute accuracy across lineboxes 12). Thisallows excellent time stamping of the received ‘Ping,’ which issomething that generic Bluetooth beacons and GPS do not have. Also, theactive transmitters can be directional antennas. The active transmitterscan be based on Radio Frequency (RF), but some customers might beconcerned about RF and an alternative is to use ultrasonic sensors.Reflections can be filtered out by the system due to longertime-of-arrival of reflected paths. With multiple transmitters, amajority vote can help eliminate a problematic path. If the transmittersare located at the rear of the frame, they can be powered more easily.In a preferred embodiment the transmitters are located at the 8 cornersof the corebox 14 itself, so no need to mount transmitters on the frameand power them.

In another embodiment, the rail 62 can include small connectors todetermine Shelf ID (SID) information from the linebox 12 to location onthe rack 60. The electrical connectivity can be via a small USB-C jumperfrom the side of each linebox 12 into a vertical rail that connects intothe corebox 14 with controllers 18. Alternatively, this could be viafree-space RF/optical connectivity.

Each linebox slot carrier 70 can have a SID coded via Dual In-linePackaging (DIP) switches (or EPROM) that is configured with a slotnumber at manufacturing. When a linebox 12 is plugged into the slotcarrier 70, it can read the SID. SID values can be sparse so that a newslot carrier 70 can be optionally inserted between two existing carriersand assigned a new SID number without having to change existing slotcarriers 70. For example, the spare numbering can be in increments of 5,10, etc.

In yet another embodiment, there can be some printed pattern on the rail62 that continuously varies over the full length of the rail 62, e.g.,barcode, Quick Response (QR) code, etc. The linebox 12 can scan thispattern using optical or magnetic sensors. The pattern can be a printedlabel or pre-etched into the metal.

In yet another embodiment, the position sensor 152 can be aMicroelectromechanical systems (MEMS) barometer pressure sensor. Thesecan be accurate within +/−5 cm. In the same way that anemometers canallow a weather station to measure barometric pressure in the presenceof high winds and gusts, an anemometer can be used to calibrate thepressure sensor in a telecom room, data center, etc. The compactanemometers can be based on measuring the temperature change of a fixedheat output device, e.g., lower temperature means higher airspeed. PitotTubes can be used to eliminate some sources of airflow that might affectthe pressure measurement. The pressure at 1 m above sea level is101312.99 Pa. At 1.07 m above sea level, the pressure is 101312.12 Pa,so the difference is 0.87 Pa, which is detectable by the current stateof the art.

Upgradeable Backplane and Evolution Across Technologies

The Field-Replaceable Units (FRUs) on the corebox 14 have a connectorthat does not change. That FRU connector can mate directly to anothercard in an ortho-direct ‘backplaneless’ system. The same FRU connectorcan connect into a standard backplane. The same FRU connector canconnect into a midplane that provides receptacles for cable headers thusallowing a cabled backplane. The cables can be electrical or optical.

If the cables are optical, then active circuitry “bump in the wire” canbe part of the cable to handle the Electrical-Optical(EO)-Optical-Electrical (OE) conversion. In order to support this, powerand ground outputs are provided on the connector to power thebump-in-a-wire. This is not normally done on existing backplanes. Analternative to locating the EO-OE conversion as part of a bump-in-a-wirecable, the EO-OE can be performed at a powered “patch” panel.

All together this enables an FRU or linebox 12 to work in differenttypes of chassis: ortho-direct, backplane, midplane, cabled electricalbackplane, and the optical cabled backplane. Therefore, the linebox 12system can work into all of these and evolve from one to another even inthe field. With cabled backplanes (electrical Twinax or optical),hitless backplane field upgradeability is supported.

To maintain compatibility and upgradeability, signals are routed fromconnector A column to connector B column; no crossovers between columns.The row-to-row routing uses “Long-to-short” to optimize pair-to-pairskew. The corebox 14 provides output power on the backplane connector topower backplane bump-in-a-wire. The granularity of cable bundles enablesonly a subset of the links that need to be unplugged at one time. Powerand ground outputs provided on the connector with appropriate managementof return currents for low Electromagnetic Interference (EMI).

Variable Bandwidth Slots

As described herein, the modular network element architecture 10provides flexibility in the expansion. There are two types systemsizing, namely configurable size at the factory and configurable size atthe customer premise. For example, in many cases, customers will simplyorder ‘small’, ‘medium’, or ‘large’systems that have enough spare cablesfor them to add new lineboxes 12 as desired. In addition to the numberof cables, the cable granularity is also important because it allowssome lineboxes 12 to get more bandwidth than others. For example, aJericho-based linebox 12 (Jericho is a switching Application SpecificIntegrated Circuit (ASIC) available from Broadcom) could use 36 linksand a Jericho2-based linebox 12 could use 72 links even though bothboxes are 1 U physical size. If the cable bundle granularity is 12-linksper bundle, then both of these lineboxes 12 can be accommodated in asingle system. The same cable granularity can be used for scale byallocating fabric bandwidth efficiently.

A system could support 3 Jericho2 lineboxes 12, 6 Jericho lineboxes 12,or 12 Arad lineboxes 12 (Arad is a switching ASIC available fromBroadcom). None of this is possible in existing systems, e.g., a 10-slotchassis system will support up to 10 of a given card regardless ofwhether that card has Arad, Jericho, or Jericho2. Cable granularity isfurther determined by the number of fabrics present. If there are 3fabrics, then there might be 12 cables going to each fabric for a totalof 36 links per virtual slot. A Jericho2 linebox 12 might use twovirtual slots worth of cables for a total of 72 cables. All of this canbe determined at manufacturing to create flexibility not possible inexisting backplane systems.

Multi-Shelf Expansion

It is possible to expand a system by adding corebox 14 fabrics andhaving direct connections between them. In the chassis-based approach,this is known as “multi-shelf” and involves creating a multi-stagefabric. This is possible with the modular network element architecture10. However, with the modular network element architecture 10 there is aunique possibility to add a corebox 14 to a system that already has acorebox 14 and maintain a single stage fabric. Essentially, the secondcorebox 14 doubles the number of fabrics. So, if a corebox 14 had 3Fabric Elements, then two coreboxes 14 have a total of 6 FE's and thesystem size can double. The challenge is how to re-distribute the cabledlinks from the existing lineboxes 12 that are only connected to thefirst corebox 14. So, if 12 links were going to each FE within a corebox14, then 6 of those 12 links per FE would need to be moved to the secondcorebox 14. Part of the design is to choose these cable granularities atcable manufacturing that allow the desired level of expansion oncustomer premises. However, it is also a way of building different sizedsystems at manufacturing. Existing approaches can require the design ofnew backplanes, power supplies, fabric cards, in order to producesystems of different sizes. Whereas the modular network elementarchitecture 10 can achieve this expansion through cabling. In‘multi-shelf’ expansion, the key point is that links are dual-use—theycan connect corebox 14 to linebox 12 or corebox 14 to corebox 14. Thisis not done in existing systems.

Hitless Upgrade

Consider a system with 3 fabrics with 12 cable links going from alinebox 12 to each fabric on the corebox 14. If the fabrics areprotected 2+1, then 2 fabrics are sufficient to pass full rate. So, each12-link cable bundle can be replaced one bundle at a time while theother two cabled bundles carry all the traffic with their 24 links. Somedeployments might not have a 2+1 redundancy ratio; they might want a30+6 link redundancy ratio. In that case, a cable bundle granularity of6 links might be more conducive to hitless upgrade. This kind ofgranular backplane upgrade is not possible in existing systems.

For the cabled case, a switch can be included on the cable latch thatsends a signal to the software that is used to take traffic off thatcable so that no in-flight fabric data is lost when the cable is pulled.This signal can be sent to both ends of the cable bundle so that TX andRX data can both be taken off pre-emptively.

Linebox

FIG. 25 is a block diagram of an example implementation of a linebox 12.As described herein, the linebox 12 is an all-in-one design thatprovides flexibility, an optimal faceplate area and board volume,optimal framing as needed, an optimal architecture, power, andinterconnect. In this example, the linebox 12 is 1 U high and has 24faceplate ports 200. The faceplate ports 200 can connect to framingcircuitry 202 which can provide OTN, no framing, MACSec, coherentDigital Signal Processing (DSP), Forward Error Correction (FEC), etc.The linebox 12 can include a power supply 204 as needed for theapplication (100 W, 400 W, 1200 W, etc.) and fans 206 for cooling. Thelinebox 12 can also include the processor 34, a Network Processing Unit(NPU) 208, and fabric circuitry 210. The fabric circuitry 210 caninclude various FAPs, FEs, etc. as needed for the application.

The linebox 12 approach can include some of the following options. Foroptics, the linebox 12 can include, for example, 1 Gb/s SFP ports, 10Gb/s SFP ports, 100 Gb/s CFP (100 G Form-factor Pluggable), 100 Gb/sCFP2, 100 Gb/s CFP4, 100 Gb/s QSFP28 ports, Coherent pluggables, CFP2Analog Coherent Optics (ACO), etc. The fabric circuitry 210 can includevarious different implementations such as, for example, Petra-B 100 G,Arad 200 G, Jericho 700 G, Qumran 800 G, Jericho+800 G, Jericho2 2400 G,Xpliant, Intel FM (Fulcrum), etc. The framing circuitry 202 can includenone, OTN, MACSec, etc. The modular network element architecture 10 canhave various sizes, power/slot, fabric density, numbers of fabrics, anddifferent backplane connectivity (e.g., Twinax, PCB, and/or activeoptical cables).

Corebox/Twinax Cabling

FIG. 26 is a block diagram of a front view and a rear view of anotherimplementation of the corebox 14. FIG. 27 is a diagram of a Twinax cable300 and connector 52. The corebox 14 in FIG. 26 includes three switchmodules 16 and two controller modules 18. The rear view of the corebox14 illustrates the Twinax connector field 54 which supports 16 cablesper module 16. Here, the corebox 14 supports 1 or 2 cables from theTwinax connector field 54 to each linebox 12. Each cable can have 12links from each switch module 16 and control links from the controllermodules 18. The Twinax cable 300 can include 72 pairs (36 links) andthis example corebox 14 can support up to 16 cables. The Twinaxconnector field 54 is configured to split the 72 pairs (36 links) into24 pairs (12 links) to each switch module 18.

Process of Deploying a Modular Network Element

FIG. 28 is a flowchart of a process 300 of deploying a modular networkelement. The process 300 includes connecting a linebox slot carrier to arack (step 302); providing a linebox in the linebox slot carrier,wherein the linebox is a hybrid between a rack mounted module and a linemodule which is inserted in a chassis, and wherein the linebox slotcarrier connects the linebox to power connectors and data connectors(step 304); and providing a core chassis (corebox 14) including one ormore switch modules, one or more controller modules, and a set ofconnectors located at the rear with cabling to the power connectors andthe data connectors on the linebox slot carrier (step 306). The process300 can further include providing a second linebox to a second lineboxslot carrier responsive to increase capacity of the modular networkelement (step 308). The second linebox can be added to the core chassisin-service.

In another embodiment, a modular network element includes one or morelineboxes 12 which are a hybrid between a rack mounted module and a linemodule which is inserted in a chassis; one or more linebox carriers 70which are rack mountable and configured to selectively receive the oneor more lineboxes 12 and provide power connectors 52 and data connectors64 thereto; and a core chassis (corebox 14) including one or more switchmodules 16, one or more controller modules 18, and a set of connectors54 located at the rear for cabling to the power connectors 52 and thedata connectors 64 on the one or more linebox carriers 70. The one ormore lineboxes 12 can include a plurality of faceplate ports 200connected to fabric circuitry 210 communicatively coupled to the one ormore switch modules 16 via the cabling; and the one or more switchmodules 16 are connected to one another and the one or more controllermodules 18 via a midplane 50 or cables.

The cabling can include one of electrical cabling with a plurality ofpairs of Twinaxial cable and optical cabling. Each cable between alinebox 12 and the core chassis can include a plurality of bundles eachhaving a plurality of links and a number of the plurality of bundles isbased on a number of the one or more switch modules 16. A chassismanagement protocol is implemented between the one or more lineboxes 12and the core chassis, and wherein the one or more lineboxes 12 and thecore chassis are managed as a single entity. The chassis managementprotocol implements, between the one or more lineboxes 12 and the corechassis, timing synchronization, presence, status, ownership,interrupts, reset, power, and position identification. The one or morecontroller modules 18 provide power and connectivity to a FieldProgrammable Gate Array (FPGA) or other circuitry on each linebox forestablishing the chassis management protocol to power the linebox on andoff.

The core chassis can include an access panel 20 that supports the corechassis and each of the one or more lineboxes 12. Each of the one ormore lineboxes 12 includes a display 150 which provides a virtual slotnumber based on a relative position in a rack. The one or more lineboxes12 can include a plurality of lineboxes 12 with at least two lineboxes12 having a different pitch. The one or more lineboxes 12 can include aplurality of lineboxes 12 with at least two lineboxes 12 having one ormore of a different number of faceplate ports 200 and a different typeof pluggable optics. The one or more lineboxes 12 each include anEthernet switch 30 which connect to another Ethernet switch 40 in theone or more switch modules 16. The one or more linebox carriers 70 caninclude retractable pins 72 with a spring-loaded mechanism that grabsinto holes in rails 62 on a rack 60 and which has a push to disengagemechanism enabling front-only access to the rack. The one or morelinebox carriers 70 have slack in the cabling to the core chassisallowing movement up and down the rack 60.

In another embodiment, a modular network element includes one or morelineboxes 12 which are a hybrid between a rack mounted module and a linemodule which is inserted in a chassis, each of the one or more lineboxes12 includes a plurality of faceplate ports 200 connected to fabriccircuitry 210 and a processor 34; and one or more linebox carriers 70which are rack mountable and configured to selectively receive the oneor more lineboxes 12 and provide power connectors 52 and data connectors64 thereto. The one or more lineboxes 12 can include a plurality oflineboxes 12 collectively forming a mesh therebetween via the dataconnectors 64, and wherein one of the plurality of lineboxes isdesignated as a primary linebox for implementing a virtual controller ofthe modular network element via the processor 34. A core chassis(corebox 14) can be added in-service to increase capacity of the modularnetwork element, wherein the core chassis include one or more switchmodules, one or more controller modules, and a set of connectors locatedat the rear for cabling to the power connectors and the data connectorson the one or more linebox carriers.

Process for Ethernet Path Selection

FIG. 29 is a flowchart of process 320 of Ethernet path selection in amodular network element. The process 320 is implemented in a modularnetwork element including one or more ingress line modules, a pluralityof switch modules in a chassis, and one or more egress line modules,wherein the one or more ingress line modules and the one or more egressline modules are located separate the chassis and connected to thechassis via cabling. Of note, the line modules can be the linebox 12 andthe chassis can be the corebox 14, although other embodiments are alsocontemplated. The process 320 includes distributing one or more Ethernetflows from the one or more ingress line modules to the one or moreegress line modules via the plurality of switch modules (step 322);receiving fabric state information at the one or more ingress linemodules from the chassis out-of-band via the cabling (step 324); and,responsive to congestion on a path through the plurality of switchmodules, selecting a new path by an ingress line module for an Ethernetflow (step 326).

The process 320 can further include, prior to switching the Ethernetflow to the new path, creating a gap in the Ethernet flow throughbuffering such that the gap is no larger than a path delay differencebetween a current path and the new path (step 328). A size of the gapcan be set to a latency of the current path minus a latency of the newpath plus a margin. The process 320 can further include distributing aTime Division Multiplexing (TDM) flow by fragmenting the TDM flow andsending over a plurality of paths through the plurality of switchmodules (step 330).

The process 320 can further include distributing timing from the corechassis out-of-band via the cabling, wherein the timing is determined atthe core chassis using a Time Division Multiplexing (TDM) flow which isspread over the plurality of switch modules (step 332). The core chassiscan utilize a TDM packet header to estimate relative path latencydifferences. The process 320 can further include broadcasting a pathselection by each ingress line module to all other line modules and thecore chassis for each to maintain a global path table (step 334). TheEthernet flow can include an elephant flow and each flowburst of theelephant flow is eligible to take a different path if its interburst gapis larger than a difference in latency between a current path and thenew path.

In another embodiment, a modular network element configured for Ethernetpath selection includes one or more ingress line modules (lineboxes 12);one or more switch modules 16 in a chassis (corebox 14); and one or moreegress line modules (lineboxes 12), wherein the one or more ingress linemodules and the one or more egress line modules are located separatefrom the chassis and connected to the chassis via cabling, wherein oneor more Ethernet flows are distributed from the one or more ingress linemodules to the one or more egress line modules via the plurality ofswitch modules, wherein the one or more ingress line modules receivefabric state information from the core chassis out-of-band via thecabling, and wherein, responsive to congestion on a path through theplurality of switch modules, a new path is selected by an ingress linemodule for an Ethernet flow.

Prior to switching the Ethernet flow to the new path, a gap can becreated in the Ethernet flow through buffering such that the gap is nolarger than a path delay difference between a current path and the newpath. A size of the gap can be set to a latency of the current pathminus a latency of the new path plus a margin. A Time DivisionMultiplexing (TDM) flow can be fragmented and sent over a plurality ofpaths through the plurality of switch modules. Timing can be distributedfrom the core chassis out-of-band via the cabling, wherein the timing isdetermined at the core chassis using a Time Division Multiplexing (TDM)flow which is spread over the plurality of switch modules. The corechassis can utilize a TDM packet header to estimate relative pathlatency differences. A path selection can be broadcast by each ingressline module to all other line modules and the core chassis for each tomaintain a global path table. The Ethernet flow can include an elephantflow and each flowburst of the elephant flow is eligible to take adifferent path if its interburst gap is larger than a difference inlatency between a current path and the new path.

In a further embodiment, a core chassis (corebox 14) in a modularnetwork element configured for Ethernet path selection includes one ormore switch modules 16; one or more controllers 18; a midplane 50 forcommunication between the one or more switch modules and the one or morecontrollers; and cabling for communication to one or more ingress linemodules and one or more egress line modules, wherein the one or moreingress line modules and the one or more egress line modules are locatedseparate from the chassis and connected to the chassis via the cabling,wherein one or more Ethernet flows are distributed from the one or moreingress line modules to the one or more egress line modules via theplurality of switch modules, wherein the one or more ingress linemodules receive fabric state information from the one or morecontrollers out-of-band via the cabling, and wherein, responsive tocongestion on a path through the plurality of switch modules, a new pathis selected by an ingress line module for an Ethernet flow.

A Time Division Multiplexing (TDM) flow can be fragmented and sent overa plurality of paths through the plurality of switch modules. Timing canbe distributed from the core chassis out-of-band via the cabling,wherein the timing is determined at the core chassis using a TimeDivision Multiplexing (TDM) flow which is spread over the plurality ofswitch modules. The core chassis can utilize a TDM packet header toestimate relative path latency differences.

Process for Managing a Modular Network Element

FIG. 30 is a flowchart of a process 340 of managing a modular networkelement. The process 340 operates in the modular network element whichincludes a plurality of line modules and zero or more switch modules ina chassis, wherein the plurality of line modules are located separatefrom the chassis and connected to the chassis and/or to one another viacabling. The process 340 includes operating a management plane betweenthe plurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules viaone or more dedicated links in the cabling (step 342); managing theplurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules as asingle network element utilizing a chassis management protocol over themanagement plane (step 344); and designating one of a controller in thechassis and a processor in one of the plurality of line modulesoperating as a virtual controller as primary for the chassis managementprotocol (step 346).

The process 340 can further include providing a virtual slot number foreach of the plurality of line modules, wherein the virtual slot numberis utilized to differentiate the plurality of line modules (step 348).The virtual slot number can be automatically assigned based on aposition sensor on each of the plurality of line modules or through thechassis detecting a position of each of the plurality of line modules.The management plane can operate over Universal Serial Bus (USB) pinsand a 10 Gigabit Ethernet alternate mode which uses a subset of the USBpins. The USB can be used to bridge a plurality of protocols in themanagement plane and to determine module presence, and wherein the 10Gigabit Ethernet is utilized for Precision Time Protocol. The USB can beused for power, presence, primary arbitration, bidirectional status,health monitoring, configuration, initialization of data path, softwaredownload, interrupts, reset, LED control, I2C bridge, UniversalAsynchronous Receiver-Transmitter (UART) bridge, SPI bridge, Pulse WidthModulation (PWM) bridge, General-Purpose Input/Output (GPIO) bridge, andPCIe bridge.

The process 340 can further include communicating between the controllerin the chassis and a Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) or circuitryon a line module for establishing the chassis management protocol on theline module (step 350). The process 340 can further include selecting acandidate clock in the chassis management protocol for synchronizationand timing distribution (step 352). The process 340 can further includecontinually measuring delay over the cabling to adjust phase of thetiming distribution (step 354). The management plane can be operatedover the cabling out-of-band from a data plane.

In another embodiment, a modular network element managed as a singleentity includes a plurality of line modules (lineboxes 12); and zero ormore switch modules 16 in a chassis (corebox 14 which is optional),wherein the plurality of line modules are located separate from thechassis and from one another, and connected to the chassis and/or to oneanother via cabling, wherein a management plane is operated between theplurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules via one ormore dedicated links in the cabling, wherein the plurality of linemodules and the zero or more switch modules are managed as a singlenetwork element utilizing a chassis management protocol over themanagement plane, and one of a controller 18 in the chassis and aprocessor 34 in one of the plurality of line modules operating as avirtual controller is designated as primary for the chassis managementprotocol.

A virtual slot number can be provided for each of the plurality of linemodules, wherein the virtual slot number is utilized to differentiatethe plurality of line modules. The virtual slot number can beautomatically assigned based on a position sensor on each of theplurality of line modules or through the chassis detecting a position ofeach of the plurality of line modules. The management plane can operateover Universal Serial Bus (USB) pins and a 10 Gigabit Ethernet alternatemode which uses a subset of the USB pins. The USB can be used to bridgea plurality of protocols in the management plane and to determine modulepresence, and wherein the 10 Gigabit Ethernet is utilized for PrecisionTime Protocol.

The controller in the chassis can communicate with a Field ProgrammableGate Array (FPGA) or circuitry on a line module for establishing thechassis management protocol on the line module. A candidate clock can beselected in the chassis management protocol for synchronization andtiming distribution. The delay can be continually measured over thecabling to adjust phase of the timing distribution. The management planecan be operated over the cabling out-of-band from a data plane.

In a further embodiment, an apparatus configured to manage a modularnetwork element includes a processor and memory storing instructionsthat, when executed, cause the processor to operate a management planebetween the plurality of line modules and the zero or more switchmodules via one or more dedicated links in cabling between the pluralityof line modules and the zero or more switch modules; and manage theplurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules as asingle network element utilizing a chassis management protocol over themanagement plane, wherein the apparatus is designated as a primary inthe chassis management protocol, and the apparatus is physicallyseparate from at least one of the plurality of line modules and the zeroor more switches.

It will be appreciated that some embodiments described herein mayinclude one or more generic or specialized processors (“one or moreprocessors”) such as microprocessors; Central Processing Units (CPUs);Digital Signal Processors (DSPs): customized processors such as NetworkProcessors (NPs) or Network Processing Units (NPUs), Graphics ProcessingUnits (GPUs), or the like; Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs); andthe like along with unique stored program instructions (including bothsoftware and firmware) for control thereof to implement, in conjunctionwith certain non-processor circuits, some, most, or all of the functionsof the methods and/or systems described herein. Alternatively, some orall functions may be implemented by a state machine that has no storedprogram instructions, or in one or more Application Specific IntegratedCircuits (ASICs), in which each function or some combinations of certainof the functions are implemented as custom logic or circuitry. Ofcourse, a combination of the aforementioned approaches may be used. Forsome of the embodiments described herein, a corresponding device inhardware and optionally with software, firmware, and a combinationthereof can be referred to as “circuitry configured or adapted to,”“logic configured or adapted to,” etc. perform a set of operations,steps, methods, processes, algorithms, functions, techniques, etc. ondigital and/or analog signals as described herein for the variousembodiments.

Moreover, some embodiments may include a non-transitorycomputer-readable storage medium having computer readable code storedthereon for programming a computer, server, appliance, device,processor, circuit, etc. each of which may include a processor toperform functions as described and claimed herein. Examples of suchcomputer-readable storage mediums include, but are not limited to, ahard disk, an optical storage device, a magnetic storage device, a ROM(Read Only Memory), a PROM (Programmable Read Only Memory), an EPROM(Erasable Programmable Read Only Memory), an EEPROM (ElectricallyErasable Programmable Read Only Memory), Flash memory, and the like.When stored in the non-transitory computer-readable medium, software caninclude instructions executable by a processor or device (e.g., any typeof programmable circuitry or logic) that, in response to such execution,cause a processor or the device to perform a set of operations, steps,methods, processes, algorithms, functions, techniques, etc. as describedherein for the various embodiments.

Although the present disclosure has been illustrated and describedherein with reference to preferred embodiments and specific examplesthereof, it will be readily apparent to those of ordinary skill in theart that other embodiments and examples may perform similar functionsand/or achieve like results. All such equivalent embodiments andexamples are within the spirit and scope of the present disclosure, arecontemplated thereby, and are intended to be covered by the followingclaims.

What is claimed is:
 1. A method of managing a modular network element asa single entity, the modular network element comprising a plurality ofline modules and zero or more switch modules in a chassis, wherein theplurality of line modules are located separate from the chassis andconnected to the chassis and/or to one another via cabling, the methodcomprising: operating a management plane between the plurality of linemodules and the zero or more switch modules via one or more dedicatedlinks in the cabling; managing the plurality of line modules and thezero or more switch modules as a single network element utilizing achassis management protocol over the management plane; and designatingone of a controller in the chassis and a processor in one of theplurality of line modules operating as a virtual controller as primaryfor the chassis management protocol.
 2. The method of claim 1, furthercomprising: providing a virtual slot number for each of the plurality ofline modules, wherein the virtual slot number is utilized todifferentiate the plurality of line modules.
 3. The method of claim 2,wherein the virtual slot number is automatically assigned based on aposition sensor on each of the plurality of line modules or through thechassis detecting a position of each of the plurality of line modules.4. The method of claim 1, wherein the management plane operates overUniversal Serial Bus (USB) pins and a 10 Gigabit Ethernet alternate modewhich uses a subset of the USB pins.
 5. The method of claim 4, whereinthe USB is used to bridge a plurality of protocols in the managementplane and to determine module presence, and wherein the 10 GigabitEthernet is utilized for Precision Time Protocol.
 6. The method of claim4, wherein the USB is used for power, presence, primary arbitration,bidirectional status, health monitoring, configuration, initializationof data path, software download, interrupts, reset, LED control, I2Cbridge, Universal Asynchronous Receiver-Transmitter (UART) bridge, SPIbridge, Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) bridge, General-PurposeInput/Output (GPIO) bridge, and PCIe bridge
 7. The method of claim 1,further comprising: communicating between the controller in the chassisand circuitry on a line module for establishing the chassis managementprotocol on the line module.
 8. The method of claim 1, furthercomprising: selecting a candidate clock in the chassis managementprotocol for synchronization and timing distribution.
 9. The method ofclaim 7, further comprising: continually measuring delay over thecabling to adjust phase of the timing distribution.
 10. The method ofclaim 1, wherein the management plane is operated over the cablingout-of-band from a data plane.
 11. A modular network element managed asa single entity, the modular network element comprising: a plurality ofline modules; and zero or more switch modules in a chassis, wherein theplurality of line modules are located separate from the chassis and fromone another, and connected to the chassis and/or to one another viacabling, wherein a management plane is operated between the plurality ofline modules and the zero or more switch modules via one or morededicated links in the cabling, wherein the plurality of line modulesand the zero or more switch modules are managed as a single networkelement utilizing a chassis management protocol over the managementplane, and one of a controller in the chassis and a processor in one ofthe plurality of line modules operating as a virtual controller isdesignated as primary for the chassis management protocol.
 12. Themodular network element of claim 11, wherein a virtual slot number isprovided for each of the plurality of line modules, wherein the virtualslot number is utilized to differentiate the plurality of line modules.13. The modular network element of claim 12, wherein the virtual slotnumber is automatically assigned based on a position sensor on each ofthe plurality of line modules or through the chassis detecting aposition of each of the plurality of line modules.
 14. The modularnetwork element of claim 11, wherein the management plane operates overUniversal Serial Bus (USB) pins and a 10 Gigabit Ethernet alternate modewhich uses a subset of the USB pins.
 15. The modular network element ofclaim 14, wherein the USB is used to bridge a plurality of protocols inthe management plane and to determine module presence, and wherein the10 Gigabit Ethernet is utilized for Precision Time Protocol.
 16. Themodular network element of claim 11, wherein the controller in thechassis communicates with a Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) on aline module for establishing the chassis management protocol on the linemodule.
 17. The modular network element of claim 11, wherein a candidateclock is selected in the chassis management protocol for synchronizationand timing distribution.
 18. The modular network element of claim 17,wherein delay is continually measured over the cabling to adjust phaseof the timing distribution.
 19. The modular network element of claim 11,wherein the management plane is operated over the cabling out-of-bandfrom a data plane.
 20. An apparatus configured to manage a modularnetwork element, the apparatus comprising: a processor and memorystoring instructions that, when executed, cause the processor to operatea management plane between the plurality of line modules and the zero ormore switch modules via one or more dedicated links in cabling betweenthe plurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modules; andmanage the plurality of line modules and the zero or more switch modulesas a single network element utilizing a chassis management protocol overthe management plane, wherein the apparatus is designated as a primaryin the chassis management protocol, and the apparatus is physicallyseparate from at least one of the plurality of line modules and the zeroor more switches.